Which is Better: Red Heart Super Saver or Red Heart Comfort?

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Similarities between Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver
3. Differences in Size and Color
4. Stitch Guide and Gauge
5. Swatch Test Comparison
6. Using Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver interchangeably
7. Conclusion

Article

Introduction

In this article, we will delve into the similarities and differences between two popular products from Red Heart – Red Heart Comfort and Red Heart Super Saver. As someone who frequently uses both of these yarns interchangeably, I often get questions about their variances. So, let's explore these two products and see how they differ in terms of size, color options, stitch guide, and more.

Similarities between Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver

Firstly, let's focus on the common aspects of Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver. Both of these yarns are made from 100% acrylic fiber, ensuring durability and versatility. They are also classified as worsted weight yarn, indicated by the number four on the label. Additionally, both Comfort and Super Saver share the same washing instructions – they can be safely machine washed and dried using cool water and low heat. These similarities lay the foundation for the two yarns' interchangeability.

Differences in Size and Color Options

While there are similarities, Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver do have notable differences. One significant contrast lies in their size and color options. Comfort is a substantial skein of yarn, weighing an impressive 454 grams or measuring 792 meters in length. On the other hand, Super Saver's solid ball of yarn weighs 198 grams or measures 333 meters. It's important to note that variegated Super Saver skeins contain slightly less yarn compared to the solid-colored ones, as adding multiple colors to a single ball of yarn necessitates higher manufacturing costs.

Moving on to color differences, it's worth mentioning that the shades of red in Comfort and Super Saver yarns are distinct. While Super Saver also offers red hues, they differ from the rich red color found in Comfort. These variations in color could be attributed to the absence of a specific dye lot or a deliberate choice by the manufacturer to provide a distinct feel between the two brands. Furthermore, variegated options for both Comfort and Super Saver also exhibit differences in color choices.

When ordering sufficient yarn for a specific project, it is essential to consider how the colors are labeled for each yarn type. Comfort yarns are associated with specific color numbers, making it easier to order the exact shade you desire. In contrast, Super Saver yarns are assigned unique names. For instance, you might come across delightful color names such as "Pretty and Pink," "Spring Green," or "Dark Orchid" when selecting your preferred Super Saver shade. Regardless of the labeling approach, both Comfort and Super Saver offer a wide range of attractive colors to choose from.

Stitch Guide and Gauge

A distinguishing feature of yarn labels is the stitch guide or gauge provided. This information assists crafters in determining the appropriate hook size to use for optimal results. Both Comfort and Super Saver yarns recommend a 5.5 millimeter hook for crocheting. However, discrepancies arise when comparing the suggested stitch counts and row measurements for achieving a specific fabric size.

According to the label, Comfort yarn requires 13 single crochets worked back and forth over 17 rows to create a square fabric measuring 10 centimeters by 10 centimeters (or four by four inches). On the other hand, Super Saver indicates that 12 single crochets worked over 15 rows will produce an identical square size. These contradictory gauge recommendations may seem perplexing, as both yarns possess the same weight and fiber content.

Swatch Test Comparison

To address the confusion surrounding the stitch gauge, I decided to conduct a swatch test to compare the measurements between Comfort and Super Saver. Using a 5.5 millimeter hook as suggested, I crocheted a swatch consisting of 13 double crochets over five rows for Comfort and replicated the same for Super Saver. Upon measuring the swatches, an intriguing discovery unfolded – both swatches measured precisely eleven and a half centimeters in width by eight and a half centimeters in depth. This experiment suggests that despite the inconsistencies indicated on the label, both Comfort and Super Saver yarns are essentially the same weight and size.

Using Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver interchangeably

Considering the similarities in fiber content, weight, and the findings from the swatch test, it is safe to conclude that Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver can be used interchangeably in projects without compromising the final stitch size. Whether you opt for the vibrant shades of Comfort or the diverse color choices in Super Saver, these yarns possess the versatility to complement your crafting endeavors.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver yarns offer a plethora of options for crafters. While they have some similarities, including being 100% acrylic and classified as worsted weight yarn, there are notable differences in size, color options, and stitch gauge recommendations. However, through my own swatch test, I have determined that these variances do not impact the final stitch size. Ultimately, both Comfort and Super Saver can be used interchangeably, providing crafters with a wide range of yarn options for their projects. So, go ahead and explore the possibilities with Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver – the choice is yours to make!

Highlights

• Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver, two popular yarns, have similarities in fiber content and weight.
• The size and color options differ between Comfort and Super Saver yarns.
• Purchase Comfort yarn based on color number, while Super Saver yarn offers attractive color names.
• The stitch guide and gauge recommendations may vary between Comfort and Super Saver labels.
• Swatch tests demonstrate that Comfort and Super Saver yarns yield the same stitch size when used interchangeably.

FAQs

Q: Can I wash Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver yarns in the washing machine?

A: Yes, both Comfort and Super Saver yarns can be safely machine washed using cool water.

Q: Do Red Heart Comfort and Super Saver yarns require the same hook size for crocheting?

A: Yes, both Comfort and Super Saver yarns recommend using a 5.5 millimeter hook for crocheting.

Q: Are Comfort and Super Saver yarns suitable for the same types of projects?

A: Yes, you can use both Comfort and Super Saver yarns for a wide variety of crochet and knitting projects.

Q: Can I use Comfort and Super Saver yarns together in the same project?

A: Absolutely! Comfort and Super Saver yarns are interchangeable, allowing you to combine them seamlessly in your projects.